Institut für Strategie, Technologie und Organisation (ISTO)

Links und Funktionen



Presentations and Reports

Archive StampMBR Core Course

Prof. Dr. Tobias Kretschmer, Prof. Dr. Reiner Leidl, Prof. Dr. Andreas Richter

Course Overview

The courses "Presentations and Reports" and "Scientific Publications" both aim to familiarize students with the process of presenting and publishing scientific results. They are based on the idea that scientific progress can only be achieved through first submitting results to scrutiny by peers and then sharing them in the scientific community. Therefore, publications in peer-reviewed journals are a scientist's core output and presenting work in progress for critical appraisal is vital for later publication success.

Consequently, the course "Presentations and Reports" focuses on presentations of work in progress and on appraising papers in the form of reviews. In a second step, the complementary course "Scientific Publications" focuses on the process of submission to journals and revision.

As such, both courses contribute to the students' understanding of the complex system of conducting research, publishing one's results and participating in the scientific community. We recommend that students first participate in "Presentations and Reports" (1st or 2nd semester) and then take "Scientific Publications" (3rd or 4th semester).

Course Structure

The course "Presentations and Reports" consists of two parts: an introductory seminar and a series of scientific presentations with subsequent debriefings.

In the introductory seminar, students are introduced to the publishing process from the viewpoint of researchers. Students will understand and experience the "Revise and Resubmit" (R&R) process and learn about fair review and appropriate revision. After an initial lecture, a case study (group work on a selected manuscript) has to be performed. In the following, results and impact of the case study are discussed and an outlook is given. The study material consists of the case study working paper, lecture notes and references on the R&R process.

The presentations take place as part of the "Management and Microeconomics" (M&M) course, an open research seminar series with presentations by national and international researchers. The aim is to provide participants with experience in following and appraising presentations from both within and beyond their own area of expertise. Alternatively, presentations in the LMU CAMS seminar series may be attended.


Participants will attend the introductory seminar and seven presentations (each plus a subsequent debriefing). They will hand in a referee report on one of the papers from the presentations. Up to three of the seven presentations may be attended at the LMU CAMS; the referee report, however, will be on one of the M&M papers. The seven presentations may be attended in different semesters.


  • The course language is English
  • Attendance to a minimum of seven presentation dates is mandatory
  • Students who attended the course "Scientific Publications" before the summer term 2011 need not attend the introductory seminar; all other participants must attend (even if they already heard some presentations)
  • Students must attend the talk accompanying the paper for which they write the referee report
Dates Tuesday, 23.04.2013, 14:00-18:00, Ludwigstr. 28/VG, Room 305 (Introductory session)
Please visit the M&M page for the seminar program and venues
Credits 2 SWS in module A/I (Scientific Citizenship)
Examination Input during the lecture and presentations and a referee report on one of the presented papers
(The referee report has to be handed in before the respective presentation is held)